Research

The Conservation Law Center currently conducts research on the following topics:

Index

Choose an area to open its content. You can also click on each heading.

1. Conservation Standards: Proper Implementation of the Conservation Right

Regarding Conservation Standards and Practices, the Center is advancing in the development of the best implementation models for different scenarios, with their corresponding differentiated standards. In this regard, progress has been made in the development of Conservation Standards and Practices for differentiated scenarios, since the variability of the Conservation Right makes it essential to consider factors of particular cases related to the social baseline, the ecosystem baseline, long-term sustainability strategies, and medium- and long-term financing strategies, among others. In this context, ecosystem baselines and social baseline studies are considered, as well as management plans for the environmental patrimony, thus avoiding the implementation of uniform traditional models that apply only the same “Conservation Standards”, considering the conservation right only as an easement, charge or restriction -which, instead of generating value, involve a reduction of patrimonial value-. These traditional models are normally related to the use of single “Guarantors” or “Custodians” and are linked to philanthropic financing models based on donations -with a limited time horizon-. This implies that such models concentrate the ´normative power´ of the Conservation Right for the benefit of such Guarantor or Custodian entities, centralizing decision-making without greater inclusion of the various stakeholders and without necessarily being oriented towards the social and economic sustainability of the project -thus generating uncertainty about its long-term sustainability-. The Conservation Standards and Practices promoted by our foundation aim to implement the ‘ecosystem approach’ of the Convention on Biological Diversity, the guidelines and categories of the International Union for Conservation of Nature, as well as Natural Capital Methodologies, in order to ensure: (a) Ecosystem adaptation of the established legal governance structure; (b) Social adaptation and integration of the established legal governance structure; (c) A consideration of the affirmative value of the environmental patrimony; (d) A legal governance structure that generates or facilitates the generation of autonomous economic flows from conservation initiatives. See the website www.derechorealdeconservacion.cl for updates on the subject.

2. Analysis and In-Depth Study of the Conservation Right Institutional analysis of the conservation right

(a) Analysis of the conservation right in relation to the different conservation standards and categories of the IUCN (International Union for Conservation of Nature), and in light of the norms of the Convention on Biological Diversity; (b) Comparative assessment between the conservation right and the ‘conservation easements’ of the United States of America, and analysis of the problems of the traditional conservation standards and practices originating in the Land Trust Alliance of the U.S.A., adopted in Chile by some conservation NGOs without considering the institutional differences of the different legal systems and regimes; (c) Analysis of the conservation right in relation to the international and local regulatory frameworks on wetlands; (d) Analysis of the conservation right in relation to the markets and regulatory frameworks for biodiversity compensation and mitigation; (e) Review of the reflexive potential of the institution in light of its implementation on the different ecosystem services; (f) Economic analysis of the implications of the conservation right, in particular as a new solution to the tragedy of the commons.

3. Regulatory Models of Conservation in General

Regulatory models are researched on the basis of the analyses carried out since the 1980s regarding the limitations of interventionist law –also called ´regulatory law or welfare state law´. In this period, work began on possible post-regulatory models, notably those of ´reflexive law´ (Ref. Gunther Teubner), ´responsive law´ (Ref. Nonet-Selznick), ´procedural law´ (Ref. Wietholter, Habermas) and ´contextual law´ (Ref. Wilke). All these models start from the recognition of the limitations of law to carry out ´direct external control´ of social activities, and particularly to manage growing ´social complexity´ and ´uncertainty´. The research of our Center is focused on the analysis and development of institutions founded on or consistent with a new notion of reflexive law, including the possibility of creating mechanisms that facilitate interaction-communication between the various social spheres.

4. Regulatory Models – Relationship between Public Law and Private Law

Another area of work, closely related to the previous one, refers to the conceptual and operational relationship between public and private law institutions. This is closely linked to: (a) the analysis of the ´public´ elements of private law; (b) the analysis of the ´implementation´ (´enforcement´) and ´effectiveness´ of law. In the field of biodiversity conservation, the relevance of this analysis becomes evident when one notes that the institution of the ´property right´ has been the great mechanism for implementing biodiversity conservation policies and the Convention on Biological Diversity, with regard to ´in-situ conservation´.

5. Private Law, the Property Right and Real Rights

In direct relation to the previous topic, our research is oriented towards understanding the institution of the property right and real rights, among which the following topics stand out: (a) The predominant theoretical notions of the property right as received in continental law; (b) The foundations of the faculties of access and control, and the relationship between property rules and liability rules; (c) The foundations and scope of the ´numerus clausus´ of real rights; (d) The influence of economic analysis on the current notion of the property right; (e) The possibility of designing special real rights aimed at generating links between different actors and social spheres –as a form of reflexive law-.

6. Biodiversity Conservation and Other Public Policies

The intersections between land-use policies, agricultural policies, forestry policies and biodiversity conservation are researched.

7. Global Environmental Law

The emergence of global -non-state- environmental law is researched, particularly with regard to biodiversity conservation. This also includes studies of global constitutionalization, particularly from the perspective of socio-legal theory, regarding the constitutionalization of normative structures of different global social spheres that influence the development of fundamental or constitutional norms of the environment.

8. Constitutional Law of the Environment and Biodiversity

The development of constitutional normative structures is researched, with particular emphasis on the role that the ´ecosystem approach´ of the Convention on Biological Diversity can play in this context, and also with reference to the discussion of the Chilean Constitutional Convention (2020-2021) regarding the theories of the commons, the Public Trust Doctrine and the rights of the earth.

Request specialized advice

If you would like information or support on the Conservation Right, you can write to us using the following form.

    Privacy Preference Center